This Needs to Stop

Alex Rodriguez

Other than FIFA, the MLB is the world’s most archaic league. No professional sports league in North America is as slow at adapting to modern changes than Major League Baseball. It took a lifetime in and a half for Bud Selig to finally install an expanded replay system.

While the importance of history in the game of baseball cannot be underscored, its rich history prevents the league from moving forward. The illogical phrase preventing change of “this is how it has always been done” rings truer in the game of baseball than it does anywhere else.

Last night, Boston Red Sox pitcher Ryan Dempster gave us his variation of the ever-constant vigilante justice we see in baseball. Dempster took it upon himself to send a cryptic message to Alex Rodriguez. He threw one pitch behind his knees, two pitches far enough inside for a half-blind person to understand what was going on and finally plunked A-Rod high and tight.

It was an unprecedented moment in MLB history.

I can’t lie. I smiled after seeing that 4th pitch bean baseball’s most polarizing figure since Barry Bonds retire. My baseball coach in high school, Dave Empey, was Ryan Dempster’s coach and is still his friend to this day. When I saw that 4th pitch fly into A-Rod’s elbow, I could hear Dave, in his old, cranky voice telling us in one of his pre-game speeches, “Ryan Dempster was a man!” Granted, Ryan Dempster doesn’t have to bat in the American league.

However, the biggest takeaway from this incident has to be the MLB’s ignorance of the vigilante justice that has been as integral to the game of baseball as the Kardashian’s are to late-night TV writers. Players and fans accept it, as we do with so many other things in society, because “that’s the way it has always been done.”

The vigilante justice pitchers impose when they bean an opposing does make some sense. Human beings are wired for revenge. An eye for an eye, right?

In this day and age though, that foolhardy acceptance of such a simple concept needs to change before someone gets hurt.

There has been no hotter topic than the issue of concussions in sports over the past few years. The NFL and NHL have gone out of their respective ways in attempts to minimize head injuries. The games have changed as a result of it.

The MLB is happy with vigilante justice. It means that, for the most part, they don’t have to deal with the straining process of determining suspensions. Accepting and recognizing it as simply a part of the game ensures that they don’t have to be the bad guy. Say what you want about Roger Goodell, but he has no qualms with being the bad cop.

Although the concept of vigilante justice does make some sense, when you break it down, it’s about as ridiculous as a monkey wearing a cowboy hat and riding a dog. Players hurl a rock hard object, the baseball, at the bodies and sometimes heads of opposing batters at speeds of 90-100 mph from 60 feet away. It may be considered justice in the game of baseball but, in a court of law, that sounds a helluva lot like assault with a deadly weapon.

Yet the majority of players and fans still seem to be fine with it.

Ryan Dempster continued to pitch. Joe Giradi was ejected for standing up for what was right. Curt Schilling said on the radio this morning that he couldn’t believe that C.C. Sabathia didn’t take it upon himself to stand up for his teammate.

Baseball mentality at its finest.

The MLB has been lucky. Despite the countless number of balls that have flown intentionally and unintentionally at the heads of players, no one has been seriously injured or killed. This may sound crazy but the ‘law of being due’ ominously looms over the game like a dark, stormy cloud. With the amount of balls that are purposefully flung at delicate human heads, it’s only a matter of time before someone sustains a life threatening injury.

It just takes one ball to hit the wrong spot, helmet or no helmet.

Major League Baseball has to get a better handle on this. Pitchers who intentionally toss balls at players should be suspended. A zero tolerance policy. It takes something to the degree of what Ryan Dempster did yesterday for the MLB to hand out one of those 6 game, 1 start suspensions.

Those 6 game suspensions have to be the bare minimum. Even though I still smirk when I think about Dempster’s best Batman impersonation, he needs to be made an example of. I know he won’t be but he should be. It can’t be up to the pitchers to do the dirty work. It’s not fair to the pitchers and it’s even less fair to the often time’s innocent (star) players who have to bear the brunt of the pitcher’s dirty work.

I don’t think I can count on my fingers how many times Bryce Harper has been thrown at in his very short MLB career.

Like so many things in life, significant penalties are the only way to change the culture. It’s the only way vigilante justice in baseball can be reined in. We can’t continue to stand idly by and tolerate players putting their lives on the line every time a team feels the need for retribution.

This is an important issue that is constantly swept under the rug by that dreaded nostalgic mantra. I get it. That’s how it has always been done.

But, come on. Let’s not wait until something tragic happens.

Agree? Disagree? Reply in the comments section below or e-mail me at

Also, you can follow me on twitter @chrisrossPTB and I will happily return the favour.

About Chris Ross
Questions, comments, suggestions? Send yours to Follow me on twitter @paintstheblack

11 Responses to This Needs to Stop

  1. Brian Penn says:

    Chris, Agree on the justice thing. Something needs to be done although I’m not sure what. I do like the fact that players police their own game and that hot dogging or showing up the other team isn’t put up with, as was the case in the latest Bryce Harper dust up. The beanballs have to go though.

    Disagree on the extended use of replay in baseball and wrote this post with my points:
    I’d hate for the entertainment value of MLB to slide to the level the NFL has with all the hot dogging after first downs and touchdowns and the delays created by how replay has been implemented there. Good thought provoking post, thanks! Brian

  2. Fitty Stim says:

    “Pitchers who intentionally toss balls at players should be suspended.”

    Ignorant statement. Who can say for sure when a pitcher throws “intentionally” at someone?

    Plus the point about the instant replay suggests a lack of insight into baseball. While fine for determining whether or not a home run has been hit, replay will only cause problems when used in other situations. How far will runners advance? What happens when a batter is called out and then replay overrules the out? Does he go to 1st or 2nd. What happens to the runners on-base who slowed down? Do they get to score?

    It’s a can of worm and this ridiculous two challenges won’t last very long. And WTF is up with the extra challenge after the 7th inning? Do umps make more bad calls later in the game?

    • Chris Ross says:

      You determine it by situation. It it is often pretty damn obvious. If it’s an 0-2 count in a tight game with men on base, it’s likely he wasn’t throwing at him. Let’s say Ryan Dempster doesn’t throw at A-Rod again and only throws that one behind his knees. Try and tell me that’s not intentional. It’s like head shots in the NFL. If it’s questionable, players don’t get the benefit of the doubt. Simple as that. It may be unfair sometimes but if you want to eliminate the danger then you have to be willing to punish people.

  3. I agree with a lot of what you said up here, but as a former ball player I am still stuck in the old baseball mentality. You show up the pitcher-you get beaned, you throw at my guy-I’m throwing at you. I still can’t believe that of all pitchers, Dempster was the guy to hit A-Rod. 2 years ago, Matt Holliday took a cheap shot at Castro sliding in late to blatantly take Castro down. Dempster was pitching the next day, didn’t throw at Holliday and said on Chicago radio that there was no point to it. I don’t know what changed his attitude but at least it was fun to watch.

  4. Anthony Richard Conigliaro (January 7, 1945 – February 24, 1990), nicknamed “Tony C” and “Conig”,[1][2] was a Major League Baseball outfielder and right-handed batter who played for the Boston Red Sox (1964–67, 1969–1970, 1975) and California Angels (1971). He was born in Revere, Massachusetts and was a 1962 graduate of St. Mary’s High School (Lynn, Massachusetts). During the Red Sox “Impossible Dream” season of 1967, he was hit in the face by a pitch, causing a severe eye injury and derailing his career. Though he would make a dramatic comeback from the injury, his career was not the same afterwards.

    Be hit by a pitch derailed this man’s career….

  5. patton26 says:

    Good article. And I am still laughing at the five game suspension and that it really only amounts to a one game suspension because of pitchers being on a five-man rotation. Way to go baseball. Still doesn’t get it.

  6. SportsChump says:

    I’m no baseball purist, CR, but to be honest, I don’t mind exacting a little revenge. Allow me to play a little devil’s advocate.

    You and I are teammmates. Someone throws at you. I’m a pitcher. I’ll be damned if I’m gonna let someone toss some chin music to one of my boys without retaliation. They’re just drawing a line in the sand.

    Look, baseball has the potential to be very dangerous, intentional or not. Shit, in football, guys are carted off the field every weekend.

    I’m down for the game modernizing but I’m also okay with keeping some of the old school toughness intact.

    Besides, as you suggest, it was A-Rod so who gives a shit?

    • Chris Ross says:

      Chris, I don’t disagree with most of what you’re saying. It’s natural for us to want revenge, which is why we accept it as okay to do. The problem is, if someone gets really hurt (see: Jason Heyward who is luck he only needs 2 plates in his jaw), then what? Someone gets hurt badly possibly life threateningly bad for a little revenge? What better revenge is there than having a pitcher on a potential rival team out for 2, 3, 4 starts down the road?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: